Various pros and cons come with the use of charcoal and gas smokers. The great debate - Charcoal Vs. Propane. The smoke you see when grilling comes mostly from drippings from the food hitting the hot coals. Let’s take a look at how they stack up against each other. I've done both in the ECB a lot (using lump charcoal) and the flavor I get outside of the rub is all wood. One of the best things about a propane smoker is that they are reasonably compact, lightweight, and … I have a charcoal smoker (ECB) and a propane smoker (Masterbuilt). If you are still confused about them and cannot decide which appliance to invest in, these pieces of information can help you. Propane smokers can be brought up to heat quickly, and it is easier to control the temperature with gas than it is with organic combustibles, like wood, pellets, or charcoal. Propane vs Charcoal Smoker: Pros and Cons. Charcoal and electric smoker are two cooking devices that serve similar use with the propane smoker. Propane smokers don’t require access to electricity as do pellet and electric smokers. Four of the most popular types of smokers today are electric, propane, charcoal, and wood pellet smokers. So take a deep breath and let's not turn this into a shouting match!!! Fear not, your days of searching ‘propane vs. charcoal smoker’ to find the differences are over. Electric Smoker . For thousands of years, humanity has smoked meat using wood and charcoal. Differences between charcoal and propane smokers. If they want high quality construction, pay for it and buy a MAK pellet smoker. The debate burns brighter than all the hullabaloo about the best smoker. I just did my first pork butt in the gasser, I did a chicken a couple of weeks ago in it too. Since it needs to be plugged into an outlet, an electric smoker isn’t as portable as other options. Actually which one is better charcoal vs propane smoker? Owners complain about cheap construction, but when they look at the receipt it is usually under $200, so I don’t get their complaint. Note to reader: These opinions are sarcastic, strong, partially rude and arrogant. Charcoal Smoker Looking at these two options shows you what a tough call it would be when choosing between them. Initially I didn't want to weigh in on this topic. Charcoal makes a tiny bit more smoke than gas, although, when lit properly, good charcoal produces little smoke and it is not likely to get into food that is cooked quickly such as burgers, hot dogs, or even steaks. If you want something that offers both reliability and great performance, propane smokers are the way to go. If you’re all about push-button convenience, the electric smoker is for you. Dec 24, 2017 - The controversy over the best smoker continues to stir up between charcoal smoker lovers and propane smoker enthusiasts. A Personal Preference. This makes them more portable. Propane Smoker vs. Charcoal Smoker & Electric Smoker. This was written as a joke but became so popular that I decided to keep it posted online. While there may be a lot of confusion, hopefully this article will help clear the air about the differences between propane and charcoal smokers.